Report: State Auditor Gives Rebuttal to Gov. Bentley’s State of the State Address

By: ,
Source: Alabama Today

Photo shows Gov. Robert Bentley, left; State Auditor Jim Zeigler, right

MONTGOMERY – In an unusual move, a Republican elected official gave a rebuttal to Gov. Robert Bentley’s “State of the State Address” today.

Republican Alabama State Auditor Jim Zeigler attended Bentley’s speech, but then gave his own rendition Wednesday, saying, “The state of the state is a mess.”

Two conservative groups requested Zeigler respond to Bentley’s address, the Alabama Tea Party Conservative Coalition and the Common Sense Campaign.

Spokesman for the groups, Dr. Lou Campomenosi, said, “Tax-paying, anti-establishment conservatives have a right to hear a rebuttal from one of their own.”

Zeigler rejected Bentley’s call for an $800 million bond issue that would pay for four new state-of-the-art prisons to replace all of Alabama’s current prisons. He instead proposed a cost-free reduction in prisoners termed “voluntary relocation.”

Zeigler said the state’s costliest agency, Medicaid, could saves tens of millions a year with a plan he calls the “Live at Home Plan.” He says Medicaid home care for seniors is less than half the cost of nursing home admission.

Zeigler’s rebuttal can be read in its entirety below.

For more information, contact Zeigler at 251-656-0292 or

Read Zeigler’s rebuttal:

The State of the State is a mess. This could not have been made more clear as Governor Bentley once again betrayed Alabama taxpayers with plans for bigger government and increased spending as a solution to our problems. This embrace of Democrat principles comes in the wake of a tumultuous 2015 in which Gov. Bentley disappointed Alabamians with flip-flopping and repeated betrayal of our values and his campaign promises.

This stew needs to be stirred. As the Governor said: “The urgency, the challenge is now.”

The legislature has received budget requests that are out of balance.  They are about $225 million in the hole on day one.  The Governor decided not to present any plans for solving that shortfall.  The good news is that he did not propose any tax increases.  The bad news is that he did not present any plans for saving money in state government by eliminating:

Waste, mismanagement, duplication, and low-priority spending.

And he did not present any plans for promoting: New efficiencies, cost-savings, and better ways to get things done for less money.

We have an admission by the Governor that there is a huge imbalance in budget requests over revenues.  We have the Governor’s decision not to do anything about it.

What we saw was a complete abandonment of budgetary duties by the Governor.  He has abdicated his leadership.

One of the problems in the Bentley administration is that the Governor and his advisers believe a budget shortfall can be solved only in two ways – by raising taxes on the citizens of Alabama or by cutting services to the citizens.  As a result of this misconception, we saw six state parks closed by the Bentley administration.  We saw a bungling attempt to close drivers’ license offices in 31 counties.  And we saw the State Auditor’s office cut by about 25%, much more than any other agency was cut.

I suggest a third alternative – not raising taxes on the public and not cutting services to the public – but a better option I call THINKING OUTSIDE THE TAX.

THINKING OUTSIDE THE TAX is delivering needed state services at a lower cost.  A substantially lower cost.  This cannot be done with the same old approaches that got us into this deficit situation.  It will take entirely new approaches. Thinking outside the tax.

One example is the state Medicaid budget.  It is one of the largest and fastest-growing parts of Alabama’s general fund budget.  With the growth of our elderly population, the Medicaid budget by itself has the potential to bankrupt state government.  Unless we think outside the tax.

I have an option for consideration of the legislature and the Medicaid agency.  I call it the LIVE AT HOME PLAN.  Right now, it costs the Medicaid agency around $6,000 a month to pay for a Medicaid patient in a nursing home.  And for the rest of the seniors’ life no matter how long they live.  Granny would prefer not to go to the nursing home.

She and her family would rather she live and die in the comfort of her own home.

Unfortunately, Alabama Medicaid pays for only a small number of patients on home care.  The irony is that home care can cost Medicaid less than half of what the nursing home costs.  Around $3,000 a month or less, rather than $6,000.

A few baby steps have already been taken toward Medicaid home care.  This has been enough to show that home care works.  It is cheaper – half price or less.  And the seniors and family are happier with Granny living at home.

What we are suggesting is not an unrealistic, novel program but an aggressive stepping up of Medicaid home care that has already been proven to work.

Nursing homes and their important lobby should not be opposed to the Live at Home Plan for two reasons.  One, many nursing homes are at capacity and have waiting lists.  As the number of seniors increases, the waiting lists will become longer.  The Live at Home Plan can help solve this problem of growing waiting lists.  Second, a small but growing number of nursing homes are diversifying and adding home care services in addition to the residential nursing care, a logical extension.  The legislature should look at an automatic or expedited certificate of need approval for nursing homes wanting to add Medicaid home care.  This provision could help win support of the important nursing home lobby.

The Live at Home Plan would save Alabama Medicaid tens of millions of dollars a year, starting immediately.  THINKING OUTSIDE THE TAX.

A second large and growing area of expense is state prisons.  The Governor proposed a bond issue for prisons, which would of course have to be repaid by obligating Alabama taxpayers over 20 years.

Studies have concentrated primarily on how to solve the prison crowding problem in order to avoid a potential federal court takeover.  What the studies largely did not do was THINKING OUTSIDE THE TAX.

Alabama taxpayers provide more money each year for a prisoner than for a school student. And more money for a convict that for active-duty military. Alabama taxpayers do not want to pay more for inmates than for students and military.

We badly need a return to old, time-honored approaches to corrections.  Approaches that cost far less than providing the present prison facilities.  THINKING OUTSIDE THE TAX.

We will ask the legislature to consider a far cheaper way to safely reduce our prison population than simply building more facilities at taxpayer expense.  So-called experts have had years to come with solutions to Alabama’s prison crowding problem. They have not done so, at a risk of federal court intervention.  When those failed experts hear of this novel approach, which is actually an adaptation of an old-fashioned, time-honored approach, they will scoff and make fun.  Don’t listen to these business-as-usual failures.  Consider the common sense approach I have named “VOLUNTARY RELOCATION.”  Here is how it could work, with emphasis on WORK: Qualifying inmates who have served a certain amount of time would be allowed to VOLUNTEER for voluntary relocation. As a condition of early release, they would agree to go at least two states away from Alabama and not return.  They can make their own arrangements for work and living arrangements there.  Or they can go, with private business assistance, to one of those places in the U.S. which have a large immediate need for unskilled labor.  For those healthy, non-violent, non-addicted inmates who qualify, they can have a good job waiting for them.  The employer would agree to transport the workers there.

If an inmate on voluntary relocation violates his terms of release and is caught back in Alabama, he will be revoked to serve out the rest of his original term.

I fully expect the so-called experts and political commentators to thoughtlessly scoff at my voluntary relocation plan. The taxpayers will not. They would prefer a program at no taxpayer expense to get the inmates away from Alabama rather than the big tax bill to keep building prisons and pay for an all-expenses-paid stay in the prison motels. THINKING OUTSIDE THE TAX.

The Governor made no mention of the proposal for “Zero-Based Budgeting” to significantly reduce the cost of providing services by each state agency. We support that proposal and insist that it be true baseline budgeting and not in name only.

The Governor made no mention of the state parks which he earlier threatened to close unless the legislature passes additional taxes. The closure last year of six state parks was not necessary. The parks internally generate around 85% of the funds needed for their operation. With minor tweaking, the parks can become self-sufficient, requiring no taxpayer funds. That is our proposal to the legislature.

The legislature has before it a bill to enable the Governor to appoint a “Taxpayer’s Advocate.” We are 100% against having the Governor make this appointment.  To have Governor Bentley appoint a Taxpayer’s Advocate is like having the fox guard the hen house. We will seek to amend the bill so that the State Auditor will appoint the Taxpayer’s Advocate subject to ratification by the Alabama Senate.  If this is not done, the Legislature could save the salary and benefits of the Taxpayer’s Advocate by simply vesting its duties in the State Auditor, who is already salaried. Merely put the duties and staff of the proposed Taxpayer’s Advocate under the State Auditor, who is already performing taxpayer advocacy above and beyond what that office had done in the past.

Appointing a duplicate Taxpayer’s Advocate could itself be a waste of taxpayer’s money.

The Governor made no mention of the important second-amendment rights to allow Alabama people to better defend themselves and their families. We will support the bill to recognize the right to carry a gun in your vehicle without a gun permit. We ultimately support universal carry, recognizing the God-given and constitutional right to keep and bear arms with no permission needed from the government. We call this “Constitutional Carry.”

The Governor made no mention of the vital issue of pro-life and stopping the abortion industry in Alabama.  We support the bill to stop abortion clinics within 2,000 feet of a school.

The Governor made no mention of preserving our heritage and stopping the politically-correct obliteration of monuments to Veterans and other historical items. We support SB13, which would make it illegal to remove or tamper with monuments to Veterans without approval of the legislative council.

We will also seek to add an addition to this bill that would mandate that the portraits of Governors George and Lurleen Wallace be returned to their legal and historical spot in the capitol rotunda.

The Governor made no mention of the 23,000 Alabama families who prepaid for their children’s college tuition only to have the state lose much of that money with ill-advised investments. These families are not receiving what they paid for and what the state had agreed to provide – four years of college tuition. We have a plan to have the colleges simply honor those contracts and admit the qualifying students who have already pre- paid.  It will cost no taxpayer dollars.

The Governor made no mention of The Student and Parent Privacy Protection Act. We support this bill by Rep. Arnold Mooney to restrict what data on students that schools can gather and share.

The legislature has before it legislation to prevent Syrian refugees from coming into Alabama.  We support a stronger, more effective approach.  We are against Syrian refugees coming into the United States anywhere.  If an Islamic militant comes into the United States elsewhere, he or she is mobile enough and well-financed-enough to travel to Alabama. The French terrorists had come into Greece disguised as refugees and they easily got to France.  We need to support America first and keep the refugees out of our country, not just out of Alabama.

We call for an independent investigation into the state’s new STAAR software. It does not work. Millions in state bills have gone unpaid or late. The procedures by which the contract was awarded are questionable.  We ask the legislative branch to designate an investigative team consisting of one member of the house and senate, the state auditor, and a representative of the Montgomery County District Attorney’s office. Notice that we have purposefully left out the State Attorney General’s office. They have had ample time to do something about this already and have no interest in this major problem. We do not want an AG on this investigation.

The State of the State is a mess. The taxpayers ask the legislature to exercise their constitutional checks and balances with the strongest steps to right the ship of state.

Jim Zeigler, State Auditor